A profound division currently grips the Irish Senate over the contentious Gambling Regulation Bill, with heated debates breaking out during the bill’s committee stage in the Seanad (upper house). The proposed legislation, designed to introduce severe restrictions to regulate gambling promotions, stirred up fiery discussions, especially between Minister of State at the Department of Justice James Browne (pictured above, left) and former Minister for Justice Michael McDowell (pictured above, right).

Controversial advertising

At the heart of the controversy is the bill’s approach to regulating inducements—offers or incentives designed to encourage gambling. Senator McDowell publicly condemned the government, accusing it of enabling gambling companies to lure people into gambling. He claimed that the “shameful” bill’s provisions would allow companies to continue their aggressive promotional tactics. His remarks triggered an immediate and harsh response from Minister Browne, who accused McDowell of making groundless and provocative claims, including allegations that members of the government had been influenced by the gambling industry.

Balance and compromise

Minister Browne clarified that the bill intends to ban targeted, individual inducements, such as VIP offers or special odds, while still allowing general promotional activities. This balance, he argued, is essential to prevent exploitative practices while allowing regulated advertising. McDowell, however, remained unconvinced, calling for an outright ban on all forms of inducements, arguing that even general promotions could exacerbate gambling addiction in vulnerable individuals.

Independent Senator Lynn Ruane and Labour Senator Mark Wall also voiced their opposition to any form of gambling promotion, asserting that gambling could lead to severe consequences. Wall pointed out that approximately 130,000 people in Ireland struggle with gambling addiction, with many at risk of relapse due to the temptation of free bets and similar offers.

Despite the opposition, the bill passed the committee stage with a vote of 17 to 5, moving it closer to becoming law. It is expected to return to the Seanad next week before final consideration in the Dáil (lower house).

Rising concerns over youth exposure to gambling ads

The contentious debate comes in the wake of a revealing the pervasive exposure of young people to gambling marketing. Conducted by Maynooth University and Ulster University, the study showed that young viewers are being overwhelmed by gambling-related advertisements, particularly in sports broadcasts and on social media. Events like the Paddy Power World Darts Championship were found to include over 1,100 references to gambling in less than three hours of airtime, with social media platforms using humour and celebrity endorsements to further promote betting.

The report concluded that traditional advertising regulations are failing to protect younger audiences from the constant bombardment of gambling messages. The study’s authors called for stricter regulations, with some recommending that sports broadcasts heavily saturated with gambling ads should be explicitly labelled as sponsored content. Professor Aphra Kerr, one of the study’s authors, argued that if Ireland is serious about reducing gambling harm, media companies and sports organisations must end their reliance on gambling-related revenue.

The findings have added fuel to the already heated discussions in the Senate, with Anne Marie Caulfield (pictured above, middle), CEO-designate of the soon-to-be-established Gambling Regulatory Authority of Ireland, reiterating the need for stricter controls. Caulfield stressed that the bill’s advertising restrictions, such as the 5:30 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. watershed on gambling ads, are necessary to protect vulnerable individuals, especially young people, from the harms of gambling. As the Gambling Regulation Bill inches closer to becoming law, the deep divisions within Parliament and growing public concern over gambling-related harm suggest that this issue is far from being settled.

Unlock winning moments: Discover the best odds on SiGMA Play.